CMC-1 Replacement Arthroplasty Versus Trapeziectomy

Plain-language summary

Thumb carpometacarpal (CMC-1) osteoarthritis is a common condition causing pain and disability, particularly among middle-aged and older women. When non-operative treatment fails, surgery is indicated. In Sweden, trapeziectomy (TE), with or without tendon-based adjuncts, is the standard procedure and recommended in the National Care Program introduced in 2022. However, total joint arthroplasty (TJA) has gained popularity because of reports of faster recovery and improved early function, although concerns remain regarding complications, durability, and cost. Comparative studies are therefore needed. The aim of this study is to compare patient-reported outcomes after dual-mobility TJA versus TE, with or without tendon-based adjuncts, for CMC-1 osteoarthritis using data from the Swedish Hand Surgery Quality Register (HAKIR). To reduce bias in observational data, the study will emulate a hypothetical randomized target trial. This registry-based cohort study will include adults aged 45 years or older undergoing primary surgery for CMC-1 osteoarthritis. Patients with previous CMC-1 surgery, bilateral procedures, inflammatory joint disease, or extensive missing baseline data will be excluded. Baseline is defined as the date of surgery, and patients will be followed using patient-reported outcome measures collected preoperatively and at 3 and 12 months. The primary outcome is change in pain on load measured with the HQ-8 questionnaire at 12 months. Secondary outcomes include pain at 3 months, low pain levels at 12 months, other HQ-8 domains, QuickDASH score, patient satisfaction, grip and pinch strength, thumb range of motion, time to reoperation, and postoperative complications. Potential confounders will be identified using a directed acyclic graph (DAG). Measured confounders include age, sex, surgical centre, calendar year, baseline pain, baseline function, and smoking. Unmeasured factors such as surgeon preference, patient preference, and disease severity not captured in the registry may still cause residual confounding. Primary analyses will use linear mixed-effects regression to compare adjusted mean pain outcomes between groups at 12 months while accounting for clustering by patient and centre. Secondary outcomes will be analysed using ordinal logistic regression, Cox proportional hazards regression, and logistic regression. Missing data will be handled using multiple imputation, and sensitivity analyses using inverse probability weighting will assess the impact of reoperations and selection bias

Who can participate

What they're measuring

Trial details